Hi this is Peter: If you know someone interested in pricing, please share Monetization Memo or subscribe below. The newsletter is always free 🙂.
We are changing the newsletter format to focus solely on long-form pricing content. Pure actionable pricing insights and stories without the links or events. We’ll also summarize the key action items at the top to make the takeaways clear. Have ideas for what you want to see from us? Just shoot over a note.
Today’s Takeaways - What To Do Right Now
Allocate more resources to a Free motion, as you are probably under-investing.
Stop doing Free Trials and do Freemium instead.
Target 4-8 weeks of real usage in Free before users hit a paywall.
Stop hiding your best features. Showcase your best foot forward in free and limit on depth of usage.
Stop limiting collaboration in Free. Unlimited users means better conversion.
Free is now for Enterprise too. Bottom-up adoption is becoming normalized at all deal sizes due to AI natives.
The endstate for Free is an ungated product. Get there as quickly as you can. Those that can offer instant value will be the winners.
Done right, a free motion can be the most efficient conversion engine in a SaaS company’s arsenal. A strong free experience creates a low-CAC lead pool, converts users to paid without a sales rep, and builds brand awareness in your target market.
Why Free Is the Way
Most SaaS companies stay away from Free assuming they couldn’t get it right. Building a great free experience requires upfront work: a frictionless onboarding flow, a clear understanding of where users get short-term value, and instrumentation to track usage. That effort scares teams away.
The payoff is worth it.
Once Free is set up correctly, it compounds. A great self-onboarding experience benefits both free and paid users. In an era of rising CAC and increasing competition, Free has become one of the most effective ways to break through the noise. When you treat Free as a combined marketing and sales expense, the math changes.
The most common pushback is still, “Enterprise buyers don’t buy this way.” That argument is increasingly outdated. AI-native companies like OpenAI, Anthropic, and Lovable have proven that bottom-up adoption can lead to org-wide purchases even in the Fortune 500. Products that remain heavily gated will be outpaced by those that grow through demonstrated value and word of mouth.
Despite the promise, many companies fail to see the benefits they expect. Some even abandon Free altogether and retreat to sales-led growth.
In practice, free motions fail in three ways. Here is how to solve them.
Failure #1: Can’t Pass Go
No one converts from Free to Paid. You end up with a large base of free users who consume resources but never upgrade.
This is the most common mistake. Teams are afraid of backlash, so they set limits too high.
The fix is simple to describe yet hard to execute: reduce usage limits and entitlements in Free.
Start with data. Understand how customers actually use the product when they are evaluating it. A good rule of thumb is to allow four to eight weeks of normal usage before hitting a paywall. If someone is actively using your product for six months, they should be paying.
One tempting but harmful restriction is limiting Free to a single user. It feels logical as a way to prevent team abuse, but it caps the number of advocates inside an organization. Fewer users means higher risk if your champion leaves. Collaboration is often the strongest “aha” moment and a powerful upgrade trigger.
Instead of limiting users, limit depth of usage. Identify the core action users want to take and give them just enough to get started.
Miro is a great example. They allow unlimited collaborators to showcase the power of the product, but limit the number of boards. The value is clear, and the ceiling is easy to hit.
Failure #2: The Honeypot Trap
Free is so good that customers downgrade from paid plans. Free becomes a substitute, not an on-ramp.
I worked with a $200M API company where sales reps consistently said their biggest competitor was their own Free plan. They weren’t losing deals to other vendors. They were fighting internal downgrades.
The solution looks similar to Failure #1, but with a more nuanced approach.
In most cases, you should allow a broad feature set while limiting depth of usage. Let users access advanced reporting, but only with limited history. Let them experience the best version of your product, just not at scale.
Free should showcase what your platform can do at its best.
The exception is when advanced features actively harm the experience. If a capability requires training, configuration, or heavy guidance to use correctly, including it in Free will confuse prospects and reduce perceived value. Only include features users can meaningfully use on their own.
Failure #3: Failure to Launch
Prospects never reach the “aha” moment. Free is either too restrictive, or the clock runs out before its value is realized.
This is especially common with free trials.
Most of us have signed up for a tool, gotten busy, and returned weeks later only to discover the trial had expired. Seven-day trials assume focused, uninterrupted attention. That’s not how evaluation actually happens.
New tools often take weeks or months to become habits, especially when users are just testing.
If you must use a free trial, push for 30 or 60 days. Seven days is almost always too short.
Even better, switch to freemium if you can support the ongoing infrastructure and support costs. In most cases, I recommend starting with freemium over trials.
Recent data from Kyle Poyar shows that freemium drives more paying customers overall, even with lower conversion rates, because you have more time to earn the upgrade.
Skipping Two Steps Ahead
If you want to leapfrog the evolution of Free entirely, look at ungated freemium experiences like ChatGPT.
The takeaway from the data is clear. The more value you can deliver with less friction, the better your free motion will perform.
Free doesn’t fail because it’s broken. It fails because it’s usually designed defensively instead of intentionally.
Have questions or feedback? Just reply to this. I read every email.
